Monday, May 11

Mock PhD Viva: Ariffin's

Went to witness En.Ipin's mock viva at the faculty. Boy, it really gave me a butterfly-in-the-stomach thingy. Why it has to be that scary?..why!!

Among questions/comments threw by those present at the mock viva (the questions were asked like bullets coming from all directions, like in Gaza war or something...scary)
  1. What the research is all about (in short)?
  2. What is the contribution to the BODY of KNOWLEDGE? (again and again)
  3. What's the reference style used?
  4. Motivation of study
  5. be careful with citations
  6. Are you proposing something better than what already existing?
  7. Illustration of idea taken form others' work must have reference
  8. Define your conceptual design model CLEARLY!
  9. Explain your figure in a flow that laymen can understand
  10. All abbreviations must be introduced prior to using it
  11. All terms used must be clarified (a) formal definition (b) resource (c) not something famously coined by public
  12. What theories you use in the study? Show the relationship CLEARLY!
  13. When you say MANY of something, give proof/example of MANY (2 or more)
  14. Arguments in citation taken from earlier year cannot put it as agreed with the later year.
  15. Put latest reference (if possible current year) - other than your/your supervisor work.
  16. Chronology of the technology existence must be written in a way that reader can understand it's evolution
  17. Rationale behind the study (avoid saying that "because I want to do it this way...") - give evidence with supported facts
  18. Avoid bias literature (don't only cite work done by your peers or supervisors)
  19. When you define something, make it clear either it comes from you or other resources
  20. Briefly explain all you illustrations (summary can be done in diagrams or words)
  21. Be clear with SCOPE of study
  22. Major difference between existing framework with what you are proposing
  23. Why such sample size
  24. What is your specific contribution to particular area of your study